Captain Butter Cream

The Captain Butter Cream cocktail is a delightful concoction that blends the rich flavors of spiced rum with the creamy sweetness of Buttershots liqueur, all effervescently uplifted by cream soda. This drink offers a dessert-like experience with its smooth, buttery undertones and hints of vanilla, making it a perfect choice for those who enjoy a sweet, indulgent cocktail. The spiced rum adds depth and a subtle warmth, balancing the sweetness with its aromatic spices.

The origins of the Captain Butter Cream cocktail are not well-documented, but it likely emerged from the creative experimentation of bartenders and cocktail enthusiasts who sought to combine popular flavors into a single, harmonious drink. Spiced rum has long been a favorite in tropical and tiki-style cocktails, while Buttershots liqueur, known for its butterscotch flavor, brings a nostalgic element reminiscent of caramel candies. Together with the fizzy cream soda, these ingredients create a creamy, smooth beverage that feels both familiar and novel, appealing to those who appreciate a sweet escape in a glass.

This cocktail is alcoholic, so drink responsibly! Best served in a Beer Mug or Pilsner Glass, though any glass works!

Feel free to get creative with substitutions — try different fruit types, sugar substitutes, or liquor brands. Crafting cocktails should be fun!

Shopping List

This drink uses 3 core ingredients. Click any ingredient to find more drinks featuring it:

1. Rum
2. Schnapps (Butterscotch)
3. Soda (Cream)