Peanut Butter Cup #2

The Peanut Butter Cup #2 is a decadent and indulgent cocktail that captures the rich, nutty, and creamy flavors reminiscent of the beloved chocolate peanut butter cup candy. This drink combines the smooth, nutty notes of Frangelico Hazelnut Liqueur with the buttery sweetness of Buttershots Liqueur, creating a luscious base that is enhanced by the deep, chocolatey undertones of Chocolate Liqueur. The addition of half-and-half adds a creamy, velvety texture that rounds out the drink, making it a perfect dessert cocktail for those with a sweet tooth.

The history of the Peanut Butter Cup #2, like many modern cocktails, is rooted in the creative experimentation of mixologists looking to craft unique flavor experiences. While not as famous as classic cocktails with decades of history, such as the Old Fashioned or Martini, the Peanut Butter Cup #2 reflects the contemporary trend of dessert-inspired drinks that appeal to those who enjoy the interplay of sweet and savory flavors. This cocktail likely emerged from the rising popularity of nut-flavored liqueurs and the ever-growing trend of crafting cocktails that mimic popular sweet treats. Its appeal lies in its ability to transport the drinker to the nostalgic comfort of a favorite candy in liquid form.

This cocktail is alcoholic, so drink responsibly! Best served in a Rocks or Old-Fashioned Glass, though any glass works!

Feel free to get creative with substitutions — try different fruit types, sugar substitutes, or liquor brands. Crafting cocktails should be fun!

Shopping List

This drink uses 4 core ingredients. Click any ingredient to find more drinks featuring it:

1. Hazelnut Liqueur
2. Schnapps (Butterscotch)
3. Chocolate Liqueur
4. Half and Half